Showing posts with label LGBT lit. Show all posts
Showing posts with label LGBT lit. Show all posts

Friday, July 27, 2012

The God Box

Sanchez, Alex.  The God Box.  New York, NY: Simon Pulse, 2007.  Paperback.  ISBN: 978-1-4169-0900-2. US $9.99.

Annotation:

      Paul has a girlfriend, plays sports, and is a devout Christian fighting what he believes are sinful thoughts he has about other guys.  Then Manuel, an openly gay student. moves to town and has Paul questioning everything he believes.  Recommended for ages 13/14 and older.


Book cover from alexsanchez.com

Book Talk:

Paul has a box where he puts all of his troubles.  He calls it his God Box.  It’s for all of his really big problems that prayer just doesn’t seem enough for.   He used it when his mother was sick and when his father turned to drinking.  Now he uses it to ask God to make him stop dreaming about guys because being gay is a sin, right?  That’s what his friends say, that’s what his pastor says, and that’s what he thinks the Bible says.  So Paul’s put himself into another kind of God Box because he's trying to be what he thinks is a good Christian, what he thinks God wants him to be.  He has a girlfriend, plays sports, goes to church, and does everything “right”.  But then Manuel, an openly gay student and committed Christian, transfers to his school.   Manuel makes Paul question his religion, what it means to be gay, and his place in God’s love.  In a small Texas town though, being openly gay can be dangerous.  Will Paul be brave enough to be himself and step out of The God Box?

Book Review:


              Sanchez, in his afterword, mentions all of the letters that he receives from teens who are struggling with their sexuality and their religion.  This book is Sanchez’s answer to all of those letters.  I agree with the message Sanchez was sending but felt that The God Box did not reach its full potential.  While the book did a good job of portraying Paul’s fear, confusion, and growth the rest of the characters seemed flat.  This was mainly because it seemed like they were only there to use Bible passages to debate whether being gay was a sin or not.
            Although I felt that this book fell short of what it could have been, I think that it still has a place on school and public library shelves.  It would be especially interesting to teens 13/14+ who are interested in the debate between the more traditional Christian viewpoints and sexuality as well as for teens questioning their sexuality.

Awards and Honors:
        2008- One of New York Public Library's "Book for the Teen Age"

Want to hear more?  Check these out:


Author Interviews:

Sanchez speaking at a Social Justice Conference in British Columbia schools regarding anti-homophopia and social justice


 


Saturday, July 14, 2012

Fun Home

Bechdel, Alison.  Fun Home: A Family Tragicomic.  Boston: Houghton Mifflin Co, 2006.  Hardback.  ISBN: 978-0-618-47794-4.  $19.95.
 

Annotation: 

        This graphic novel explores the at times dysfunctional relationship of Bechdel and her father from her childhood until his possible suicide years later.  Due to graphic sexual content this book is recommended for ages 17+.

Book cover courtesy of Amazon.com

Book Review:

            Fun Home, by Alison Bechdel, is a graphic novel memoir which explores the author’s dysfunctional relationship with her father, an English teacher and funeral home director in rural Pennsylvania who also happened to be in the closet.   Throughout the book Bechdel, who also is gay, questions the idea of nature vs. nurture and whether her coming out to her family played a part in her father’s possible suicide.  The illustrations are heavy in feeling being entirely drawn in shades of black, white, grays, and blues which enhances the overall somber, bittersweet tone of the author’s relationship with her father. 

The novel is rife with literary works which played a big part in the lives of both father and daughter.  Although Bechdel does a decent job of explaining the correlation and importance of the literary works and authors she mentions in Fun Home, the parallels she draws between the works and her life would not be fully understood by anyone unfamiliar with the works.  Between some of the more mature illustrations and the plethora of college level literary references this book would be more appropriate for teens 17+ and adults interested in Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual, or Transgendered literature.   In that respect this graphic novel memoir would be more suited to a public library than a school library.

Awards:
       2006- National Book Critics Circle Award finalist
       2007- GLAAD Media Award for Outstanding Comic Book
                 Stonewall Book Award for non-fiction
                 Publishing Triangle-Judy Grahn Nonfiction Award
                 Lambda Award in the "Lesbian Memoir and Biography" category
                 Eisner Award for Best Reality-Based Work


Interested in finding out more about this book or author? Check these out:

 Author site: http://dykestowatchoutfor.com/

Author Interviews:

           June 2006 Bechdel podcast at the Free Library of Philadelphia



Clip of Bechdel explaining her drawing process for Fun Home